Perry Raso (CRMC File No. 2017-12-086) Post-Hearing Briefs

• Executive Director's Report
• Subcommittee Recommendation
• CRMC Staff Reports and Reference Materials
• Raso Application Materials
• State and Local Comments
• Beutel Email Correspondence
• Notice of Public Hearing and Workshop
• Attorney Information
• Lease Photographs
• Public Comment: Letters of Support
• Public Comment: Letters of Objection
• Public Comment: Comments received after PN Expiration Date
• Public Comment received as of November 5, 2020
• Town of South Kinghstown response to 2017-12-086
• Public Comments received after Nov. 5, 2020
• Transcript 11/12/20
• Transcript 11/13/20
• Transcript 11/17/20
• Transcript 12/04/20
• Transcript 12/16/20
• Transcript 12/30/20
• Transcript 01/29/21
• Transcript 03/08/21 (Subcommittee Workshop)
• Subcommittee Meetings (virtual)

Other Materials

Received After January 23, 2023:

• Capaldi Objection 01-31-23
• D. Wagner - Intervenor Wilkes Letter Objecting to Proposed New Layout
• C Capizzo - Intervenor Letter Objecting to Evidentiary Hearing before CRMC - 1-23-23
• C Capizzo PS&H Objection to Mtg Notice 01-16-23
• R Rheault Raso Comment 01-24-23

Received January 17, 2023:

• Proposed Reduced Layout with Letter

Applicant

• Memorandum of Law
• Statement of Facts
• Exhibits
  1. Raso Application
  2. David Beutel Testimony Transcript
  3. CRMC Staff Report
  4. Perry Raso Testimony Transcript
  5. Resume of Audie Osgood, P.E.
  6. Audie Osgood Testimony Transcript
  7. Town of South Kingstown Boats and Waterways Ordinance
  8. January 22, 2021 letter from DiPrete Engineering
  9. Dr. Byron Testimony Transcript
  10. Dr. Michael Rice Testimony Transcript
  11. Dr. Rheault Testimony Transcript
  12. Payson Whitney Testimony Transcript
  13. Objectors’ Testimony
  14. ESS Report
  15. Proposed Site Plan
  16. Photographs by Perry Raso
  17. South Kingstown Waterfront Advisory Commission Meeting Minutes
  18. CRMC Public Notice of Case No. 2015-01-051
  19. Application Details for Case No. 2015-01-051
  20. RIDEM Acceptance Letter
  21. RIHPHC Letter
  22. Letter from CRMC to Town of South Kingstown
  23. Counsel’s Entry of Appearance
  24. February 7, 2018 Shellfish Advisory Panel Minutes
  25. February 15, 2018 Letter from Town of South Kingstown to CRMC
  26. Rhode Island Marine Fisheries Council Letter to CRMC
  27. APRA Request Response

Objectors

• Christian Cappizo
  • Intervenors' Post-Hearing Memorandum of Law and Statement of Facts
  • Exhibits
    • Sample Letters of Objection
    • USCG Boating Statistics 2019
    • Exhibit 1 ESS Segar Cove_Technical Memo 4-10-20
    • Exhibit 2 Segar Cove Docks and Mooring Field, South Kingstown, RI
    • Exhibit 3 Payson Whitney CV
    • Exhibit 4 Latham Photos and Video
    • Exhibit 5 Cooney Photos
    • Exhibit 6 Hunt Photos
    • Exhibit 10 SK Waterfront Advisory Commission Letter to CRMC 2-15-18
    • Exhibit 11 SK Waterfront Advisory Commission Minutes 2-1-18
    • Exhibit 12 SK Waterfront Advisory Commission Minutes 3-14-18
    • Exhibit 13 RIMFC Meeting Summary 3-14-18
    • Exhibit 14 RMFC Letter to CRMC 4-27-18
• Dean Wagner
  • Intervenors Andrew Wilkes and and 454 Beach Road LLC Memorandum

Applicant

• List of Witnesses
• Ex. 1 Duhamel CV
• Ex. 2 Rice CV
• Ex. 3 Byron CV
• ———Below Received 01-22-2021———
• Letter to A. DeSisto re Raso Supplemental Exhibit
• ———Below Received 01-22-2021———
• Raso Transmittal Letter
• APRA Request Response – RIDEM
• Letter from Mr. Osgood, PE
• ———Below Received 12-30-2020———
• Comments
• ———Below Received 11-12-2020———
• Memorandum of Law in Response to Objectors' Opposition
• Ex. 1 CRMC Application submitted by Perry Raso dated December 27, 2017
• Ex. 1a Supplemental CRMC Application Materials submitted by Perry Raso dated 3-15-2018
• Ex. 2 Curriculum Vitae of Dr. Michael A. Rice
• Ex. 3 Curriculum Vitae of Dr. Carrie J. Byron
• Ex. 4 Curriculum Vitae of Dr. Robert B. Rheault
• Ex. 5 Curriculum Vitae of Audie Osgood, PE
• Ex. 6 Site Plan entitled “Site Plan – Objectors” prepared by DiPrete Engineering, dated May 1, 2020
• Ex. 7 Site Plan entitled “Docks Plan” prepared by DiPrete Engineering, dated November 10, 2020, showing distance of abutting docks to original proposed lease area
• Ex. 8 Department of Environmental Management letter to CRMC dated January 23, 2018
• Ex. 9 RI Historical Preservation & Heritage Commission letter to CRMC, dated January 10, 2018
• Ex. 10 Department of Environmental Management Division of Marine Fisheries letter to CRMC dated February 2, 2018
• Ex. 11 Rhode Island Marine Fisheries Council letter to CRMC dated April 27, 2018
• Ex. 12 CRMC letter to Town of South Kingstown Waterfront Advisory Commission dated February 2, 2018
• Ex. 13 Certified Waterfront Advisory Commission Meeting Minutes Dated February 1, 2018
• Ex. 14 Letter of Support
• Ex. 15 Photographs of Segar Cove, Potter Pond by Perry Raso
• Ex. 16 RICRMP Category B Requirements

Opposition

• PS&H Letter to CRMC received 1/28/21
• USCG Boating Statistics 2019 received 1/28/21
• Raso Opposition Package
• Raso Opposition 1st Amended Proposed Exhibit List
• Raso Opposition 2nd Amended Proposed Exhibit List
• Exhibit 1 ESS Segar Cove_Technical Memo 4-10-20
• Exhibit 2 Segar Cove Docks and Mooring Field, South Kingstown, RI
• Exhibit 3 Payson Whitney CV
• Exhibit 4 Latham Photos and Video
• Exhibit 5 Cooney Photos
• Exhibit 6 Hunt Photos
• Exhibit 7 CRMC Public Statement - 2-16-18
• Exhibit 8 CRMC Transcript from 6-12-18 Meeting - Highlighted
• Exhibit 9 SK Conservation Commission Letter to CRMC 10-4-17
• Exhibit 10 SK Waterfront Advisory Commission Letter to CRMC 2-15-18
• Exhibit 11 SK Waterfront Advisory Commission Minutes 2-1-18
• Exhibit 12 SK Waterfront Advisory Commission Minutes 3-14-18
• Exhibit 13 RIMFC Meeting Summary 3-14-18
• Exhibit 14 RMFC Letter to CRMC 4-27-18
• Exhibit 15 Letter from RIDEM DFW to CRMC 2-2-18
• Exhibit 16 PSH letter to CRMC 2-1-18
• Exhibit 17 PSH Letter to CRMC 3-27-19
• Exhibit 18 CRMC Notice of Hearing 3-24-20
• Exhibit 19 PSH Letter to CRMC Legal - 5-19-20
• Exhibit 20 PSH Letter to CRMC Legal - 6-16-20
• Exhibit 21 Raising Objections Article Spring-Summer 2014
• Exhibit 22 Pages from 41N Spring 2020
• Exhibit 23 Shellfish Advisory Panel Meeting Summary 2-7-18
• Exhibit 24 ESS Visual Simulation Existing Conditions, Aquaculture Lease Boundary, Segar Cove, 6/29/18
• Exhibit 25 South Kingstown Harbor Management Plan, 2010
• Exhibit 26 South Kingstown Boats and Waterways Ordinance, Chapter 4

Late Request to Intervene

• Entry of Appearance Dean Wagner for Andrew Wilkes
• Motion to Intervene Dean Wager for Andrew Wilkes